I am tempted to ask if other parents and first and second-born-s agree that the second child is born with special skills to shake any smugness out of their parents, unlike the first born who lets you think you have done a great job… Do you think this is true?
The above is the question that the Indianhomemaker or IHM as she is known, has tagged me to answer. Hmmm…. The question itself is innocuous and easily answerable. What makes (now why the hell is MS Word telling me that I should use ‘make’ in the sentence here instead of ‘makes’??) me shake in her non-existent boots is thoughts about the aftermath of answering it. Is it wise at all to attempt to answer this tag? Hmmm….. On the one hand I myself am the eldest, who according to IHM are angels. Let me also make it clear I am not saying the opposite holds true of my siblings. There are two of them and one of them blogs! On the other hand I have a pair of monkeys … ok Martians, sorry sons, (anyway its all the same, people) and this sort of analyzing is going to land me in boiling hot water. Anyway who is afraid of a little hot water, boiling or not? Not me! With a sciatica ridden leg and a painful heel that has me limping around the house, a little hot water is always welcome. Good to soak my feet in. So here goes….
Ages ago, when I was a young girl in her twenties was born to me the First Born (hereafter referred to as FB nothing to do with Facebook, the social networking site). Gently skimming over the nights FB kept me awake, he following US timings as regards sleep even in those days and the near and dear ones of the Know-All Older Brigade going into frenzy about it (Why is the baby getting up so often at night?) conveniently forgetting that FB slept so soundly during the day for hours together amidst the day to day activities (Hmmm I wonder if the silence which he so loves now bothered him those days?!!) and trying to pin the blame (The baby is hungry, top feeding will solve things, a bottle would do the trick, tra-la-la and la went the ‘wise-my-foot‘ Know-All Older Brigade) on Poor Me who, though an inexperienced and first-time Mom without a single soul to speak up for her, dug her two tiny size 4 feet in, like Balaam’s ass (and I mean the animal, thank you Wodehouse) insisting that she would not only breast-feed her FB and subsequent children if any but also bring him, and subsequent children if any, up the way she wanted to, we arrive at toddler-hood. Long sentence?? Take deep breaths. The faintness will pass.
A delightful child, obedient, loving, prepared to listen to reason at all times – that was FB as a toddler. Let me add here that I got the opportunity to bring him up away from Interfering and Well-meaning (my-foot again) Grandparents and Relatives and that helped a lot in achieving the listening to reason part of the FB. Other Parents were all praise whenever I took the FB to their houses. He was so different from their brats. They sighed over him, “What a lovely child! He doesn’t trouble you!” I beamed. He never ran loose in other people’s house, break valuables or give cheeky or rude back- answers. He was Mom’s little helper. even rolling out rotis at four years of age in a reasonably round shape which even the Lord and Master couldn’t manage. He would never ask me to carry him however tired he was from walking once he was told his Mom was not keeping well and was unable to do so.
Apart from beaming at Other Parents, I also patted myself on the back. Wow, I was doing a great job. Yeah it’s true that the FB enjoyed pulling little Pooja’s hair when ten months old. When he was 15 months old, his hobby was pushing Shweta and making her cry while her Mom and I were occupied in yakkety yak yak.. At two he was pulling his cousin Lakshmi’s hair, never letting go till he had pried a few strands. But these hair-pulling and pushing adventures, me the young first-time Mom could handle with ease and panache. The FB loved his books and listening to stories. He would obediently turn on his side and go to sleep after reading ALL his ABC books and listening to about a million (oh you think that’s too high a number? Hmm… perhaps it had been only a couple of hundreds!) stories. The FB was a curious child, with an extra inquisitive mind, argumentative, yet soft spoken. But then what are Moms for if not to answer questions and argue back? All in all I was a Pleased as Punch Mom, smug in the knowledge of a job well done.
Precisely five years and ten months later was born the Second Born (hereafter referred to as SB and has nothing to do with the leading banking institution State Bank of India). Once again gently skimming over the initial days when the baby SB slept soundly waking only at infrequent intervals unlike the FB, looked after single-handedly by the now Experienced and Confident Young Mom, ready and willing to thumb her nose openly at any member of the Know-All Older Brigade who dare make any Silly Suggestions to her on How To Go About Taking Care Of A Baby, which Aggressive Attitude resulted in peace prevailing all-around (Thaadi ulla appaneye pediyullu goes a Mallu saying. Loose translation: Only the one with a beard is feared and this let me hasten to add, is metaphorical and in no way implies that I suddenly sprouted one when SB was born), we arrive at SB’s toddler-hood.
A delightful child, blue-eyed (no metaphor this) and dimpled. Obedient, loving, prepared to listen to reason,.. Errrr… ummm…. Something seems to be wrong. Ok, let me start all over again and try to get it right this time. Delightful child, blue-eyed, dimpled and loving and with a mind of his own. There I knew I’d get that right. At two he refused to wear the dress I had chosen for him not knowing that he wanted to have a say in things, and determinedly marching into the bedroom, climbed on the cot, imperiously waved his cute chubby baby hands and pointed at the one he wanted to wear. Hmmm…. Come on sweet little baby bedtime, let me tell you a story. The story session would start. A few minutes into the story, he would get up and tell me decisively, “Illa Amma! Angane alla. Jnaan parayam” (No Mom, Not that way, let me tell you) and proceed to tell me the story making the same characters of the story do whatever he wanted them to and finishing off the story in no time, then go and do his own thing, like arranging the books (or anything he found) in a row and pretending it was a train.
The SB had (still has) a LOUD voice (The Creator sent us a model with the volume control knob missing, I have always maintained) which voice he used at maximum capacity to achieve his goals. Not that this Mom was/is scared of LOUD voices, only of lizards, chameleons and mice, errr… maybe thunder too. Having the Lord and Master at home during SB’s early days, certainly cramped my style of functioning. L & M may be tall and huge compared to my puny self, five feet nothing and trying to tip the scale at 42 kgs. But he was putty in the SB’s hands. What most adults (please exclude me from the list) are ignorant of: children are pretty smart, smarter than adults who think they are smart. If you aren’t careful they wind you around their little finger and make you dance and not just the salsa but even some little known dance form of some tribe living in remote African jungles. Many a parent willingly dances till a few years down the line they wake up from the trance and go into the next parent mode which is the ‘today’s generation blah blah blah…and blah’ mode giving the children the necessary ammunition to go into their ‘you don’t understand me you old fogies’ mode. You see the catch in the dance routine? It is for a reason they say catch them young. Well, I have digressed as usual! Sigh, but that’s nothing new.
The SB ‘borrowed’ the FB’s toys, broke them, ordered him around imitating me of course. The small fact that I was the Mom, FB the elder brother seemed never to enter his tiny brain. Travelling with SB was a nightmare. He wouldn’t sit still unlike FB who was content looking out of the window of the train for hours together. SB never sat still at any time, which made my Aunt remark that she understood the secret behind my hour-glass figure. He clamored to go to school with elder brother. But when it was time to go he screamed his head off forcing the helper to abandon the cycle for fear that both of them would fall and hurt themselves and so carried him to school on his shoulder. He just did not like school.
With the arrival of SB, I stopped patting myself on the back. The beam was replaced with bewilderment. One of my cousins laughed at me,
“Chechi, how could you think you would get two of them in the same mold?”
Err.r…. ummm… Of course that’s what I had thought, but instead was rudely woken up from my idyllic dreams. You bet the smugness was shaken out of me! But come to think of it, was there such a difference?? One argued for hours though in softer tones, the other in louder tones and walked off mid-sentence. The FB never said ‘No’ when asked to run errands, but always forgot to do whatever was asked of him. The SB not only remembers, but calls from wherever he is to ask if I need something. There is more. I am the prim-and-propah Mom when out with the FB. With the SB, it is more like I am his younger sis. But however different they are, unlike some parents who discriminate between their children (Don’t even try telling me no parents do that!), for me they are the same, my children. Period.
An afterthought: Hmmm…. With all these differences, how come they both are so similar when it comes to their messy rooms??
Updated on 23/08/2012 with a link to:
Heh 😀 I can just picture Vivek back then 🙂 Exactly the same !
Me: Lol, could you?? BTW nice that you dropped in. 🙂
What a nice depiction of sibling difference. And told with a sparkle! Yes, how boring it would be if they all came out like clones…and what a mystery of life is the expression of unique personality! ~ Tim
Me: Thanks Tim. Indeed, it would be really boring if your children were totally alike. The differences make everything more interesting. It IS a mystery Tim, this expression of unique personality. There is no quick answer to explain it away.
Ahem….FBs are angels. *fluttering my wings*
The last one..messy room. Ha..ha..ha.. I remember mom saying that about my brother. I was an angel even then. 😀
Me: *flutters wings in agreement*
And they are no better now regarding the messy room! Sigh! Sigh! (The extra sigh is because one is home now and the room nay the whole house is a total mess)
first things first..
yes first born are veritable angels…not one evil thought comes to their mind ever…no sir! absolutely not!
😀
now that thats out of the way we can proceed 😀
Me: *Nods head in total agreement* 😀
First born is noticed and criticized and so they have to be good boy/good girl. Next is taken for granted. If they do any mischief too, they are not noticed! So they become bolder and bolder…there goes the story!
Me: Disagree to that Sandhya. Their personality differs. It is not the influence of parents or upbringing. We just think so. 🙂
I remember one of my friends said once you have FBs because you really are serious about having one and you are very careful and guarded with them but the SBs are normally had for fun! I was laughing hysterically when she said that!
And then suddenly she realized she should rephrase and got into that justifying mode saying its not that SBs are not taken care of,its just that they have a referring point in the FBs. It was hilarious,Shail 😀
Let me mention,she has two adorable and very well brought up daughters 🙂
Me: *Lols with Deeps*
I differ in my view from the popular notion, Deeps. That may be the case in many households, about taking the SB for granted, using the FB as a reference point etc. I have not and yet there is a difference. The reason is not so simple as we think is my opinion on it.
uh Shail?
Would it ..you know..like cancel out my first comment if I said that I was more like the way you have described your SB? 🙄
I mean I was an angel but also a *devil*
The FB was a curious child, with an extra inquisitive mind, argumentative, yet soft spoken
eh well..that would be a young SB morethan me..but.now an older ( and wiser) FB that is me 😀
The SB ‘borrowed’ the FB’s toys, broke them, ordered him around imitating moi of course.
errmmm me again
But yeah I never troubled anyone..wsnt a brat I mean (only my unbiased opnion ofcourse :D)
gimme food (ANY food)and I am yours for life was more the kind of kid that I was 😀
pssttt there were also rumours floating around that my parents didnt give me enough food…poor me 😦
Me: Hahaha Indy! You seem to have been quite a kid, devil and angel all rolled into one. And no food eh?? Poor poor you! 😦 😉
LOL, yeah they are so similar yet so different arent they. I feel first borns are amenable superficially, and seconds are rebellious, but scratch the surface, they are the same. They do exactly as they want, both ….
Me: Hmmm… I’d say they are different yet similar. 😀 And Ritu, I so understand the ‘scratch the surface and they are the same’ thing! 😛
Delightful read!! LOL at FB not being Facebook and SB not being SBI 🙂 Very nice post, examining the polarities between siblings! Just that my FB is just like you SB, therefore, I am shit scared of having a SB, even if he/she is going to be like your FB! makes any sense?!!!!
Me: Haha @ Just that my FB is just like you SB, therefore, I am shit scared of having a SB 😛 I got it Pal! 😀
First borns are poor souls always mild
as the parents have time to have them styled
and make them completely to their wishes complied
the same can’t be said about the second child.
Me: 🙂
I am a first born.As you would have guessed by now. A real ‘pavam’. With their first borns parents have all the time to pamper and be protective. By the time the second child comes, they are exhausted and tired of raising the first born and relax the ‘rules’. Reason why the second borns are stronger and smarter.Plus they have a referral point in their brother to know things and learn the do’s and don’ts.
Me: I don’t agree with the popular notion regarding why FBs nd SBs are the way they are, Govind. I have tried my best to use the same approach to SB and FB in my upbringing. But SB’s individuality came in the way and I had to modify my approach, make it stronger, to teach the same lessons. Each child has a character the source of which is deeper than merely their parent’s approach. Not all SBs are stronger or smarter and not all FBs are kadinjool pottu like they say in Mallu.
Shail,
Lol @ ‘If you aren’t careful they wind you around their little finger and make you dance and not just the salsa but even some little known dance form of some tribe living in remote African jungles’
I am a FB and a SB, since my parents were fed up raising one child.
Though I am scientific and would refrain from forming any conclusions of my own, I think there is a clear behavioural difference between FBs and SBs (we are talking majorities here; there are always exceptions to any rule), with FBs being relatively more mature and SBs being relatively more vivacious.
Cheers,
Sal
PS: Did I mention that the post was extremely well written as always?
Me: “I think there is a clear behavioural difference between FBs and SBs (we are talking majorities here; there are always exceptions to any rule), with FBs being relatively more mature and SBs being relatively more vivacious.”
I think there is a clear behavioral difference between the two too (leaving out the exceptions of course) but it is not merely the influence of parenting which seems the popular notion. It goes much deeper than that is what I believe, starting from the time the child is in the womb. Of course a lot of parents give extra time for their FBs, some in a positive way, others in a negative way, either way the FBs get a lot of unwanted attention till the SBs are on the scene. And then the SBs get all the attention, mostly positive (but which has negative effects in the long run) …. and for the rest of their life they are thought of/treated as ‘cute’ ‘helpless’ ‘younger’ ones who know nothing. An example, the L & M who takes care of everything in our own home is treated as a kid, literally, in his own home by virtue of his being the younger one there. I consciously desisted from falling into this trap of treating the SB as a ‘baby’ (even when he was not a baby any longer) and the FB an ‘adult’ (even before he was one) and insisted on going by their ages.
Thank you Salil! 🙂
Well articulated… 🙂
And all you FBs… Shail, Indy, Solilo… stop your fluttering right there…
😛
I’m an SB, a middle one of three, to boot, and I do believe that as a kid I was an ANGEL. After 10, a terror, I am told… I remember being the worst of the three as a teenager.. Lol!
Loved this tag. And am waiting to do mine too… in a couple of days, hopefully!
Me: Usha!! Oooops you a SB?? And an Angel turned Terror?? Lol, I can very well believe that!! 😛 😉 Hehehehe.. BTW am waiting to read your take!
Hahaha. Finally read it. Nice one 😀
I didn’t know about me wanting to select my own clothes until I read this. 😀
Me 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀
Thank you!
Enjoyed reading this brilliant description of FB and SB. Each child is different, and as your cousin said, “Chechi, how could you think you would get two of them in the same mold??” I have seen even twins being different. Imagine reading a bed time story to different twins, like your FB and SB – I think then the SB would read it out to the FB and matter would end – or would it???? Enjoyed your writing.
Me: I agree! 🙂 Even twins are different. I knew a set of twins who were good at different subjects. What subject one twin was good at the other was very poor in. Amazing. Their teacher was simply freaked out by this difference.
Thank you! 🙂
Pingback: When we met | Shail's Nest
OMG!!! How is this possible?! It’s the same at our place! Even though Big A was the normal, rambunctious toddler, he always listened…while Little a, as you say, has a mind of his own. If he does not want to, there is no way you can make him do anything!!
Thanks so much for linking up the Mommy Brain mixer!
Lol, is it? May be it is an universal thing? 🙂
oh my God! your SB is moi..exactly..how on earth did he become like me…my mom will tell you exactly the SAME STORY!!! my brother (elder just for the records) has been and still is, the epitome of an ideal child…and moi..ah well! lets just say me and SB are of the same mold 🙂
Teachers in our school would NEVER believe that I was my brother’s sister..well you go that na..you are V’s sister!!! they would go..and my Amma would just nod her head saying yes yes..they do share the same genes if not anything 🙂
Haha. So you are an SB too eh? 😉 Lol, they all seem to be similar by the look of the comments! 🙂
I am foreseeing this happening to me already. My elder one is an angel-simply too good to be true. He does all that I ever wanted my child to do. He loves to read, he is obedient, he is bold, he sings-well what can I say, he is my perfect little boy. Now that the second one is on the way, the visuals and play back of my second sibling’s antics is all coming back to me. Till today, my mother and the rest of us refer to her as my mom’s MIL. Yup, she’s a terror! hahaha
Ahh you better be prepared! 😉 Lol @your mom’s MIL. That’s funny. In my house the name is reseved for my dog Luci. She insists that I get off the laptop and sits watching me with approval when I work in the kitchen! :O 😛
Is this your first time here? If so, welcome to Shails’ Nest. If I am wrong, just ignore this 🙂
Ah… the FB vs. SB debate. I say, FBs rule! This is a strictly biased opinion, since I am one.
But seriously, I’m astounded to see so many parallels between your FB and me, and between SB and my sister. SBs are …. spirited would be the apt word, I think, unlike we FBs who tend to be more quieter and more mature. 😉
By the way, Shailaja Aunty, I’m Zainab and I was introduced to your blog by my aunt Razia. (I believe you posted about her once on this very blog.) She thought I’d like to widen my horizons, as I’m a blogger. And I’m so glad I saw this. I love your work, especially your humorous and/or sarcastic tone. And not to mention, your stand on women-related issues. “In the land of Maha-abuse” as well as your replies to some of the bone-headed comments on it were simply superb. *standing ovation*
Okay, I might have rambled a bit too much. Looking forward to read more!
Welcome to Shail’s Nest Zainab. So glad to meet Razia’s niece! I wrote about her here: Ringing up Razia 🙂 My apologies for this very late response. But as you might have come to know I had not been keeping well.
Thank you for the compliments. You have a wonderful page going too. I will hop over to check it out in detail, soon 🙂