Tags
They ask me the same question all the time, every single time without fail, “Do you work??” Sometimes I wonder if it is a conspiracy. Hey let’s ask Shail whether she works. Its fun!! She might just explode into a million colorful bits one of these days and its not even Diwali yet. Sweet-natured woman that I am, I haven’t as yet fulfilled these wishes of the conspirators much to their dismay. I solemnly assure you that I am no lotophagi who I gather resided (or do they still??) somewhere in North Africa and gorged themselves silly on lotus fruits and flowers and then slumbered in total apathy. Ugh! Who wants such a life anyway?!! Not me, thank you. Goodness knows what lotus flowers and fruits taste like. Besides who wants to sleep their life away and that too in apathy when there is, ummm… music to listen to, nature in all its splendor to feast your eyes on, books to read and yummy ice-creams to eat?!
This ‘Do you work??’ is a question I handle from people in droves as it were on a day to day basis. Initially it used to amuse me no end. Then it made me wonder and now finally I am resigned to my fate. I must have ‘idler’ stamped on my countenance, though I have to admit I am no eager beaver type either as lazing around comes naturally to me. But then the other question puts this doubt to rest and throws up an entirely different line of thinking. There are those who give, ‘Do you work??’ the go-bye and directly go to ‘Where do you work??’ with so much of confidence that I am indeed a career woman. Am I supposed to feel flattered, the humble homemaker forever being mistaken for the ‘Working’ Woman??!! If I am in an expansive mood, which I generally am at all times, I reply naughtily, “At home!” leaving the questioner flustered and going ‘Oh ahh’ finding their assumption lying flat on its face on the sidewalk having slipped on that unseen banana skin.
Just the other day, I was traveling by train and this gentleman, who was my co-passenger, asked me where I worked. I did not dare joke with him, he being a senior lecturer and all that. Hence in accordance with the ways of the present world, I replied that I was not. “But… but…” he said, “You speak English!” Pardon me if I roll my eyes at this point. The ideas people seem to have about career women or homemakers for that matter amaze me no end. Or maybe he left some things unsaid, the fact that I was traveling on my own in spite of err… umm….. ahem… my advanced age!! So according to his convoluted logic, I simply had to be a working woman.
There are those suited and booted sales persons who come by wanting to talk you into buying all sorts of things the usefulness of which depends entirely on whether you are the seller or buyer. I hate clutter and don’t want to pile up unnecessary things in my house. So before they can even start off on their spiel I give my unequivocal “Onnum venda!” (Don’t need anything) They on their part ignore it and go on and on about this product and that, the memorized lines in English spilling out parrot-like, while they try to impress me, the lowly homemaker (who else would be home in the middle of the day??), while I interject a ‘venda’ here and there. When I have had enough of being polite, I firmly interrupt and tell them in no uncertain terms and in English, how they are wasting their time and mine and how I didn’t want the book or the steamer or non-stick cookware or whatever gobbledygook they were selling and why. They stop in their tracks, the sales talk forgotten for the moment. The lady speaks English! There is a new look in their eyes and then the inevitable question follows, ‘Do you work Madam??’ Shhhh, don’t tell anyone!! It’s a guilty secret that I hide as best as I can!!
Once I went to the paint shop. I got the varnish, different color paints and other things I needed to complete an art work I was working on. While paying the bill, the shopkeeper who has often seen me driving to the vegetable shop next door asked me, ‘Where do you work Madam??’ A couple of days back I was at the annual function of the Residents Association. I am new to this locality. Most everyone I was introduced to asked me, ‘Do you work??’ or ‘Where do you work??’ I stepped into Bank of India yesterday and the Manager asked me ‘Do you work??’ making my Lord and Master glance hurriedly at me and laugh a little indiscreetly. At these times, I merely smile, shake my head and say ‘No.’ The smile is optional, but gracious that I am, I throw it in for free.
This do you work question puzzles me no end. I mean, what the heck, is it not work if I cook, clean or whatever it is a homemaker does?? An esteemed blogger once nearly jumped at my throat for wondering out loud in The Non-Workers?? albeit in a tongue in cheek manner, why people insist on asking homemakers, ‘Do you work??’ when what they do obviously is work too. Housework is housework and everyone has to do it, whether a homemaker or a working woman, she pompously pointed out to me. Point noted humbly and taken in the right spirit. However it fails to answer my question. Why ask someone, ‘Do you work??’ when what she does is house-work?? Isn’t that politically and technically incorrect question?? The lady in question, obviously one of the champions of the ‘Working’ Women of the World, against whom let me hasten to add I have no complaints (so all those ‘Working’ Women who even now have silently and in unison lifted those paper weights with intent to harm may relax and get back to reading), my firm belief being to each his or her own, went on to say that people asked this question as a way of opening a conversation. Oh really?? Hmmm….. And then came an uncalled for clincher from the same esteemed blogger. “Unfortunately once you find out the person does not work somewhere I think most people simply run out of things to ask after that.”
“Billions of Bilious Blue Blistering Barnacles!! Pestilential Pachyderm! Cushion Footed Quadrupeds! ” I exclaimed on reading it, borrowing liberally from Captain Haddock without permission though I am sure under the trying circumstances I was in, he would have commiserated and gladly helped me out with more of his colorful vocabulary were he present. I went so far as to accompany it with a little war dance after suitably painting myself in a suffusion of reds and oranges, all the fiery colors, with an imaginary spear in hand. “Great Flat-footed Grizzly Bear! Bald-headed Budgerigar! The lady means that homemakers are empty-headed and don’t make good conversationalists!!” I muttered to myself through clenched teeth, slowly beginning to resemble an aubergine in color. Fortunately for me, before I could die of apoplexy, I took a second look at what she had written and started laughing helplessly. If like she says, most people run out of things to say, doesn’t it reflect on their poor conversational abilities?? I mean, be fair. Should I morph into a Career Woman just so you can find something to talk to me, especially after a stupid opening like, ‘Do you work??’ How about a simple, ‘What do you do??’ instead, with a cheerful smile plastered on, if you please!!
Please change your website’s name into “Shail’s nest where imagination and vocabulary tap dance.” A simple question you made very complex with your burning imagination. Wonderful imagination and nicely written.
Vijay, I am delighted you dropped in. Thank you for the appreciation and the suggestion!! 🙂
aunty i think it is the word problem.
in malayalam, Job and Work both are called ‘joli’, right?
Job is “the principal activity in your life that you do to earn money” (word web dictionary, not my definition)
Work as you say is “Activity directed toward making or doing something”(again word web, its easy to look up to)
Here they may re-phrase the question as ‘Do you have a job?’ rather than ‘Do you work ?’…
so, i think unless malayalam has definite different words for Job & work… it will continue?
but again there comes another question….
paid job….and unpaid job, which usually is volunteer work here… and home-making can be classified as volunteer work. so, next time you can say yea, i am doing volunteer work… may be that will leave them more confused…
**** taken in light spirit ****
That is quite an explanation Swathi. But I don’t mean Malayalam. I am talking of the question that people ask in good old ‘English’!! 😉
Never mind them asking me. In reality I am least bothered. But its good fodder for blogs! And anyway, I am a homemaker. Period. 😛
My fave is “All mothers are working mothers” 🙂
🙂 🙂
Perhaps, it has something to do with the popular misconception that Stat-At-Home Moms and Homemakers are rather too involved in their home, serials, and hearth and therefore do not make interesting company… Utter B*******, I agree. Me thinks you should take the ” Do You Work?” as a compliment to your captivating personality 😛 😛 😛
And speaking of Lotophagi, Lotus plants, fruits and flowers, I gather you have not read my last post… 🙂 🙂
http://www.3madmoggies.blogspot.com
I DO get u…n since it has been asked to u numerous times…u hv got some patience n tact to tackle the same question again n again with innovation. Hope the world understands ur logic…i will pray for tht 😀
Yeah Ganga, true! 😀
Rekha, eeek, the serial junkies!! *looks up suitable curses from Captain Haddock’s repertoire* …and oh, methinks me will do a little jig for that compliment!! 😉 ..and whats this, you gorge on lotus flowers and seeds too?? :O
Amrita, back after a long gap!! 😀 Hehe… hope the world does, but right now the possibility looks a little bleak. 😉
LOL!! I so enjoyed reading this one, I was nodding here and there and giggling too especially with the salesman part…
I have been through this so many times. At first it was amusing, then it became annoying and now I dont care. Maybe I should write about my own experience hmmmm.. fodder for a blog?
Hi Shail,
I guess the question, as Swati has pointed out, is supposed to mean ‘do you work for a livelihood?’ with the latter part omitted for convenience. Now why the question is often asked to you is ‘THE QUESTION’ here.
‘I hate clutter and don’t want to pile up unnecessary things in my house.’ – well, interesting trait for a woman.
Ah, by the way, do you work? 🙂
Cheers,
Salil
Rashmi, you and I have a lot in common! Now I am waiting to read your experiences!! You know I have heard this ‘Do you work??’ so often that I positively expect people to ask me that. 😛
Hello Salil! Welcome to my space…..and of course I know what it is supposed to mean, this all important question, ‘Do you work??’ 😉 And yet, sigh! homemakers also work for their livelihood you know (in case you didn’t that is!!) though they don’t have a salary receipt to show for it. Just kidding! Now as to why the question is asked to me, errr… maybe because like the ketchup ad goes, ‘I am different’??!!
BTW I just popped over to your page and read all about plastic money. If this is a sample of your writing, you bet I am going to haunt your pages.
…and oh!! I work, verrry hard, at home!! 😛
For many women, housewifery is a valid satisfied career and has responsibility to care for her family, just as much as bringing home a paycheck. They work as much as career women, no one should ever demean that. An insightful blog, Shail mam!
what a delightful peice of writing. it simply drips charm.
Thank you Vikram. It is also a matter of choice, whether one wants to be a homemaker or a career woman which simple fact seems to escape most people. And respect for that choice is totally absent. Amazing!! ‘You have wasted your life‘ is something I hear often starting off with my own parents all of them forgetting that I am living life on my own terms, the way I like!! 🙂
Pankaj, thank you for stopping to read and leave a comment.
hello Shail
I never worked!!(i mean in a office)
but when people ask me “do you work” i always say: “only my mind is working ,not yours??
Hello Isabel! Haha, that’s a good answer!! 😉 …and its soooo good to see you here!!
i lurrrrrrrrrrrved isabel’s answer….that was EXCELLENT!
Yeah Swathi, it is an excellent one!! Three cheers to Isabel!
i guess i had been too busy working (!!!) my holidays out and didn’t get time to check your posts out earlier. my “do you work” answers are terribly convoluted – starts with yes, from home, full-time but flexible timings, for a company back in india, but busier keeping house – the description never ends!
i loved this post.
Pingback: You speak English, but you don’t work? at Blogbharti
Roopa, multiple answers up your sleeve eh?? 😛
I too have been asked this question, but only occasionally 🙂
Indianhomemaker, I am not surprised you have been asked this question!! 🙂 Glad you dropped in.
A very thoughtful post, Shail.
I think that you have found a very satisfactory question when you say:
“Should I morph into a Career Woman just so you can find something to talk to me, especially after a stupid opening like, ‘Do you work??’” OF COURSE NOT
Of course, you should not leave the path of your heart and soul and mind because others would feel more at EASE if you could Be something that they expect you to be.
Yes, this is what people should do as you suggest–How about a simple, ‘What do you do??’ instead, with a cheerful smile plastered on, if you please!!
The irony is many people probably don’t realize the value of talking and exchanging ideas with someone who has gone the “personal path” and selected family and individual values and not selected money and self-esteem through what they can do..
That a woman can work at home and be very interesting probably surprises those career types who need their work to define them and their bosses to lead them around by the noise (men and women)
You have much of value to talk about to anyone who can leap over their prejudices of what is more important–a homemaker or career woman? Different circumstances for different folks, no?
How many people work to bring the extra money to the household and give up the opportunity to be at home when their children need them?
You know these things. Others need to look into them perhaps, and to keep from harassing you for being an individual qith goals for her own life outside the work for money sphere.
Good job, Shail.
From nowonwards i will ask , what do you do….
Bob, as usual you have said a few home-truths. It amazes me to think why anyone would conclude a stay-at-home Mom is not interesting. The ability to converse and be interesting is not conferred on you by any career unless of course you work in the PR department!! 😉 Hahahaha!! Different circumstances for different people, exactly!! Something pretty simple that doesn’t seem to register with some. Ahhh Bob, I so agree with every word you have written!!
Sunder, very good! At least a homemaker will have the option of replying ‘I work at home’ rather than having to shake her head and say. ‘I don’t work’ (which is a lie anyways) 🙂
😀 hehe This is something that all home-makers should read! They may learn what to/how answer the question next time. Well… whn ppl ask me, I just say… “I am a happy home-maker”, and bah can you believe… some even asked me… “Are you a civil engr.,” :O
Most of them are apologetic about being a homemaker. I have met really few who are proud about their choice!! BTW Bubbly, why civil engineer?? *mystified*
I don’t know mumma… I remember a couple of them askin me that question,… If I am a Civil Engr., Probably they didn’t understand the term ‘home-maker’ They might have thought that I make homes 😀 Hence ‘Civil Engineer’ 😀 They would have understood better if I had said that I am a ‘HOUSE WIFE’ 😛
*light bulb flickers and then lights up* Bubblyyyyyy!!!!!!!!! Is that what they meant?? Omigosh!!!! *rolling on the floor laughing my heart out* Homemaker = One who makes homes = Civil Engineer??? Excuse me while I roll on the floor once again!! *rolls* Some one really said that??!!!! :-)))))))))
hehe I too wanted to laugh so much (Rolling on the floor) when they asked me that question! But… I somehow controlled my poor self from laughing in front of them! (hehe al though i giggled within me :D) I only hope that someone doesn’t ask me if I am a ‘House Wife’ or ‘OFFICE WIFE’ :O Gosh!!! That would have a different meaning…. hahahahahahahaha :))
Yeah Bubbly. I just haven’t figured it out yet as to why a stay-at-home woman should be housewife!! Sounds as if she married the house and not the man. Hmm… I wonder if that is true!!???!!!!!!!!! :O:O:O
Hahahaha Shail,
Quite a predicament! I had to…er… stil have to face it when people ask me….”Oh! You left your job! How do you spend time now?” with such concern for my meaningless existence! When I say, I cook a lot of square meals for the family now…read a lot…and blog, it is as though they are are humouring a pampered child… The sympathy is very evident in their eyes!
I am not much of a dusting , cleaning and rearranging -the- furniture- at -the- drop- of -a -hat kind of homemaker either… For me spring cleaning means, removing unwanted stuff from My Documents…
Why should we Non- Working women have to justify our choice?
Shail, this is my first time here, and am I glad to be here!
Deep deep empathy from me, :D, first off, for the way it still is! I must say that it’s probably the darnest, most idiotic things to ask, but then the world will… 🙂
Having been on your side of things as well, for a very very long time, till I decided to add to the work ..:D.. I already did, I know exactly what you have so beautifully, so utterly delightfully expressed! A treat, really, to read this! I just wanted to stand up, applaud, and shout.. C’mon, let’s hear it for the Home-maker!! And then I did, much to the amazement of my dogs, who were the sole audience of the performance, Lol!!
Thank you too, for dropping by at my space. Can’t tell you how glad it makes me, for I found another treasure trove in words!!
Hello Viju! Lol @ “For me spring cleaning means, removing unwanted stuff from My Documents…” I echo you, ‘why do we have to justify our choice’??!!! Not to mention the umpteen questions of ‘Do you work??’ we have to face!!! Hrrrmmmph 😦 😛
Usha, couldn’t help laughing out loud imagining your performance and the look of amazement of the dogs!! Hahaha!! 😀 Thank you, thank you for the appreciation!! I am thrilled. BTW, your poetry has me spellbound! Will be back on your page for more.
Pingback: Interesting ‘massages’ | Shail's Nest
Pingback: To speak or not to speak | Shail's Nest
– “Arts” (you thing from outer space, who in their right mind opts for arts??? Oh, I get it…) “…oh! How much did you get in the 10th?”
– “Oh how come you take math in arts? Oh it’s tough to get into science na!”
– “Lucky yaaaaaaaaa, you don’t have to work so much for exams it’s easy for you guys” (Another story that I wouldn’t even if I were in your important field :P)
– This takes the cake – we’re talking about MS (computer science) students in the US: “Oh, you people also have assignments?”
[Well, not really. They give us some blocks of shapes and colors to sort, if we can’t finish it in class time, we take it home as assignment (Yes I actually answered that once :P)]
In other words: I HEAR YOU LOUD AND CLEAR. Wonderfully written!
g
PS: I’m willing to give many the benefit of doubt that they’re just trying to make conversation – but not all of them, no.
Me: I quite enjoyed your comment! :)))) …and I agree, most definitely not all of them were trying to make conversation! 😉
Thanks for dropping by Gauri. 🙂
Clap Clap….:D You said it Shail!
PS: You forgot “Bashi Bazouks”.
*Thanks Mini! *Takes a bow* And oh yeah, Bashi Bazouks too! 😉
I find even this question, ‘What do you do?’, a little offensive. I never ask it as a conversation starter. You should have more interesting things to say when talking to a stranger. I always reply to this question with something like: not much, stuff like most people do, read , watch TV, take care of my daughter, cook, carefully avoiding any reference to my profession ( and I am a man). Then they are forced to ask but what do you do for living etc., and I again avoid the answer which they are dying to hear, only alluding to my profession, if I must, in a vague way.
Haha I am loving it here. The age old question…You work or you are a housewife?? That is what I have been questioned a lot. And yes I also say..I work at home and get the surprised looks. No one has dared to say something like “But you talk in English”, but their look says it all [May be because I look quite unpleasant/scary answering these questions].
Loved it!!
Pingback: The right to work at home | Shail's Nest