Tags
Parenting needs no license. More is the pity. That is the thought that passed through my mind as I struggled to hide the shock and dismay I felt listening to the lady who sat across me.
She had just told me very matter-of-factly that her five year old daughter begged not to be left alone at home with the orderly when she and husband attended the ‘children not allowed’ parties in the Officers’ Mess. Apparently they totally disregarded her entreaties and continued leaving her with the very person she objected to being left alone with.
“One day we returned from a party to find the orderly sprawled on the carpet in a drunken stupor…” she said calmly as if that were an everyday occurrence in most homes “…and my daughter had locked herself in her room. She had been crying.”
How many of you are feeling yourselves grow cold at this point of the narration?? To this day I remember the chill of dread I felt that day more than two decades back.
I somehow found voice to ask her if their little girl was okay staying home with the new orderly, for I assumed that they had sent the other one packing. It turned out that I was wrong. Not only was the same man being retained (because he knew all the work and was familiar with things you know) but was also continued being entrusted with the job of taking care of their daughter while they partied with career prospects in view.
“Oh, she refuses to come out of her room when we are away. She stays locked up in her room till we get back. I cant stay back. My husband insists that I attend parties with him.” she added as if that settled matters for her.
I was silent. I was a junior officer’s wife, new to the station. Protocol did not allow me to counsel the L & M’s boss’s wife. Besides, my own retiring nature balked at the thought of interfering in other people’s business (which is a shame in this case).
I tentatively asked the lady if she knew why her daughter refused to come out of her room while the man was around.
“We don’t..”
She shrugged her shoulders as if the matter of finding out why exactly her daughter felt unsafe was of least importance.
How could she?? How could he?? How could they as parents not ‘hear’ what their child was trying to say?? Why leave your child (and that too alone in a house) with someone she seemed to be frightened, someone with whom she did not want to be left alone?? It simply seemed to defy any sort of logic to me. Was the ambitious father’s career, to help which the mother had to be by his side socializing, take precedence over the welfare of their child?? The dam burst once I was back home and I vented my feelings without restraint to the L & M. But a fat lot of good that would do to the child.
This neglect on the part of parents was generally known and discussed in hushed tones by the rest of the crowd, some of them scornful about the parents, others pitying the child and still others cursing the orderly. But none of us sadly enough, took the initiative to take up the matter with the parents, to help the child.
I still think of her and wonder how parents can be so callous as to dismiss the fears of their children because it disturbs the way of life they have outlined for themselves. I remember her with guilt, with a feeling of failure for not having at least spoken a word to help the child.
“Child Sexual Abuse is a topic which is rarely discussed in India thanks to the social stigma and cultural taboos associated with it. Nonetheless, research does show that over 53 per cent of our children, across SECs, geographical locations and age groups report some degree of sexual abuse.”
That is the official figure. But if you really get down to it and speak to those around you, you will find that 90 per cent of all of us have in some degree or the other experienced some form of sexual abuse as children.
This month (April) has been devoted to the cause of spreading awareness about the menace that is Child Sexual Abuse, across blogosphere, by the initiative of two dedicated ladies, Monika Manchanda and Kiran Manral. It is commendable work they along with their friends Boo, Iya Malhotra and Sunayana Roy are doing, especially in the face of harassment from trolls and skepticism from some more.
One of the points that have been mentioned by experts is of ‘taking due note and acting on it when your child refuses to be with someone or other’ which is when I remembered this incident that happened years back, where the parents failed miserably (and so had the onlookers who did not try to help, even with words).
Please listen to the children, believe them and help them. Most of all don’t betray them by sweeping under the carpet what they have to tell you and forcing them to continue as if nothing untoward has happened. The least you can do is accept the existence of wounds and try your best to heal them.
Child sexual abuse has life long repercussions. It is not just something that you read in the newspaper, something that happens to someone else’s child. It happens right in our homes under our noses because in most cases, it involves people known and trusted by the family. Don’t be one of those foolish people who think only girls are affected. Boys are equally at risk and affected just as much.
The answer begins with staying aware and vigilant at all times. So please all of you, go through the survivor stories, tips on how you can help an abused child, how you can recognize if abuse is happening and other means of increasing awareness at the CSAA blog here. Also take a look at this report, Study on Child Sexual Abuse 2007 (a downloadable pdf file).
Related post:

My head is aching now, reading about the child’s trouble – her parents. I just don’t know what to say.
@Sandhya,
Yeah, these things render us speechless in shock.
I had forwarded some good articles about CSA to my young relatives. Everybody will be working after they get married and somebody who is reliable should be at home to take care of their future children. I know children are not very safe in the outside world also. We can do nothing about that but just pray, Shail.
@Sandhya,
You have done a good thing. CSA awareness is a must. Maybe that is what we can do, Sandhya. These 5 ladies are doing a wonderful job.
Horrible! This was one self absorbed and ignorant person. You’re right Shail, she did not deserve to be a mother. Shocking
@Phoenixritu,
Really shocking when your child’s cry don’t reach you. This surely is ‘undeserved’ parenthood.
poor girl. Sometimes parents could be really dumb.
And what about all those exhibitions hanging out there Shail . I really feel women should be given the right to shoot them at sight . I cannot thank enough our Malayalam teacher , a nun actually, who talked to us girls that all those exhibitionists out there are real cowards , And that we can catch ourselves in time , and that we can effectively train our eyes into a neutral to look past all these vulgarities .
@Krishnaleela,
These are more than dumb. Callous would be more apt. Your reference about the exhibitionists reminds me of a 55-word story I wrote. I will post it one of these days. I must say that your teacher did a good job in talking to you all.
It was one such orderly who tried to molest my sister when my parents were home!!
The poor girl kept quite for a couple of hours, but not being able to keep it to herself for any longer, she confided in Dad who took the necessary action ASAP!
I think it is important that parents cultivate the kind of environment where the children feel comfortable enough to confess their fears and insecurities.
I’ve been a victim too, but for some reason, I don’t have the will to come out in the open with it.
But I make sure that I keep checking on my kids from time to time, asking them during playtime if someone has touched them where they shouldn’t have! With a large family and plenty of relatives dropping by, I can never be too careful.
Thankfully,the kids have replied in the negative till now and that gives me some solace 🙂
@momofrs,
Absolutely. Communication lines should always be open. Parents should be approachable for children too. I hope your experience is something you are able to handle and not let affect your life. I hope you have been following the blogs at CSAAM. With two little ones of your own, its better to be armed with all the necessary knowledge. 🙂
I’m boiling with rage thinking about those parents..I mean, HOW COULD THEY??? Even after that poor girl so clearly told them not to leave her with that man, how could be they be so heartless to have disregarded her??
I agree with momofrs, it is very important for parents to ensure there is open communication between them and their children. Every child needs to be assured by their parents that they are free to talk about their fears, doubts,anxieties or unpleasant experiences, that they WILL be heard. But unfortunately even today, many of us parents, switch channels when a condom AD is shown on TV or theres a programme on AIDS or when there is an intimate scene being shown. Talking about sex is still taboo. If we stop being escapists, we can address this issue even better.
@Deeps,
Yeah, one does feel anger at the thought of how the child’s fears were rubbished, how she was left alone with someone she feared for some reason.
Yeah there should always be openness between parents and children, and willingness to talk about whatever bothers. I have seen parents asking kids (and that too not in a nice way either, as if whats on TV were somehow the child’s doing) to switch channels when suggestive dances come on TV. It is better to let them watch only age appropriate programs in the first place (the importance of which is not recognized by the country as a whole!!).
Shail I got goosebumbs reading this. How could the parents be so callous? WTF IS WRONG WITH THEM? They need psychiatric treatment. What I also feel awful about is that are lakhs of couples who are struggling to have children but who are not blessed. And here we have parents who are so blessed yet treat their most precious kids as a piece of furniture!!! Can you not report them to the police? I mean, like an ANON caller?
@Writerzblock,
I feel the same. You have childless couples longing for children and here those who have them treat their child as dirt.
This happened two decades or more back, Pal.
What godawful parents! Am seething… and literally shaking… having read this. How could they not have listened to their little girl?
And this becomes the bottom line, the one reason it continues to rampage… the fact that we refuse to listen. That we refuse to believe. And if we ignore it, we feel, it wil simply disappear. The trauma that the poor child undergoes… the shame, the fear, all unexpressed can be terrible.
@Usha,
The bottom line: not listening. Yes, that’s it. Reading the posts on the CSAAM blog proves how the trauma of CSA lasts a lifetime.
SAD.. dont know what to say .. such people shud not be parents ..
@bikram,
I agree, they should not be!
Very thought provoking article Shail and quite sadly, an evergreen topic. Constant vigilance is necessary along these lines for sure.
One of the things that I really feel lucky about being in the US is that the educational system includes awareness of such topics, both on the parts of the children as well as the parents. This is one of those areas where it is a dubious distinction that it is not a gendered issue – both young boys and young girls get molested.
It is a difficult thing to read about but an important one. Thanks for writing about it.
@Brenny,
Thank you. And that is something that should be incorporated in the educational system here too. But I think we have a very long way to go before that happens.
Difficult at the same time important read, yes, that’s what it is.
And nice to see you after long Brenny! 🙂
Pingback: To Sum It Up – 8 « CSA Awareness Month
Oh….what a shame to be such parents!
It’s terrible to even think of such situation where your kid is begging you to not leave u alone and crying and locking herself up and all it means to the you is a small ignorable story from your life. It’s shocking!!
But then am sure there are many many more like these. Thats why we need to be aware ourselves and also make such parents aware of what all a simple request from your child can mean.
@Bharti,
Welcome to Shail’s Nest and thank you for the comment.
CSA awareness assumes all the more importance under such circumstances where parents neglect to ‘hear’ their child.
Shocking!! What kind of mother she was?? I mean, not getting it, even after a clear message from the kid!! Was she ignorant or tried to be an ostrich about the situation?! Whatever it was… disgusting it is!! What psychological scars the parents and that sick man inflicted on the lil kid! Sad! 😦
@Shilpa Garg,
The parents refused to see the message even though it was like neon lights shining right in their faces. I hope she is alright now wherever she is.
How utterly callous of the parents. That poor child. In such a sticky kind of situation I guess an anonymous warning letter might be justified. But what terrible parents. The mind boggles- the child is clearly stating her discomfort and they chose to ignore it. God alone knows what that poor child went through.
@dipali,
Welcome to Shail’s Nest and thank you for the comment.
Callousness is the word for it, pretending not to or refusing to hear your child’s cry.
I am going to be thinking about the five year old… Can’t understand such parents but we do come across them around us all the time.
In case of girls, the same indifferent parents become ‘very strict’ when the child reaches puberty – it seems her safety, happiness, trauma and self worth etc. is of no concern, but fear of pregnancy is.
@Indian Homemaker,
Yes, one does come across such people. One of the survivor stories was about a mother who did not speak up ever for her daughter. She did not tell the father. And mutely stood by when the grandmother and the uncle turned against the 15 year old. It made me so angry just reading it.
Yes, I agree, all the strictness is to keep the girl ‘pure’ till marriage, no one cares for anything else. It would seem from the extreme lengths people go to , as if parents are under contract from society to ensure virgins for the marriage market. I wonder if any parent in these circumstances has paused to THINK what exactly they are doing.
The five year old must be a grown up now. I hope to God that she does not blame herself for what she went through as is the wont of most abuse victims. As to the parents, they are a sad reflection of our social degradation.
@Vivek,
I hope so too. She already had the makings of a child with self-esteem issues, the way she looked at her parents almost begging for approval. I recognize them anywhere and my heart goes out to them. I want to tell all such children, “DON’T!!! You are good as you are, in fact too valuable to seek approval of unworthy people though they be your parents.”
I better not start off on such parents.
Its sad to know that parents think that their career is more important than their kids’ welfare….and am so angered that they refused to look into the matter.
I sincerely hope that the girl is a survivor and have overcome those moments in her childhood.
@UmaS,
Yeah it seemed, he wanted the wife to be with him socialising and the child could lock herself up to keep safe! Unbelievable, isn’t it?? I hope the child is a survivor and has been able to put these times away.
Pingback: links for 2011-04-12 « Unjustly
Your story is chilling, Shail. Leaves one speechless.
On a side note, since you have been kind enough to individually mention the team (thank you :)), please note that Boo of http://boosbabytalk.blogspot.com/ is also a part of the 5-person core group.
@csaawarenessmonth,
Sorry about that. I will update the post, pronto! 🙂
My stomach churned as a I read your graphic account.
I agree, a license is desirable for becoming parents, or perhaps even to get married.
How foolish on our part! We insist on a license if we wish to drive a scooter, but not for marrying and begetting and raising children.
I agree with Dipali who said an anonymous warning letter would be justified. I would do that now if I am confronted with such situation.
But that might work for most parents. Would it have worked with this particular parent? They were too wrapped up with their social lives to even care about the child. I feel sorry for that child which must be an adult today and if she were a blogger, an account of her childhood memories on this issue would be another stomach churning reading session for all of us.
Sorry for this long silence.
I was totally pre-occupied with personal/health/ and career related issues and took a break from the internet except to check personal emails.
There is a big back log of emails to be responded to.
Catching up on previous blog posts of yours and a few others, is not practical now.
I hope to be able to read your future posts and participate by commenting.
Regards and best wishes
G Vishwanath
@G Vishwanath,
‘Too wrapped up in their social lives to care about the child’ covers the situation. Yeah some sort of license seems appropriate for marriage and for becoming parents.
Nice to have you back. I hope you are doing well now health-wise. Take care.
An extremely passionate and well balanced argument which I think succeeds very well in pointing out how we refuse to admit what is happening under our noses. In spite of the evidence.
@earlybird,
You hit the nail. How we deluge ourselves in spite of the evidence! Thanks for dropping by.
Till they day we learn to walk over “stigma” and talk about it, i guess these things will continue to “prosper” !!
You do read TBG’s blog, don’t you? Haven’t you seen the attitude pple have against overcoming what is “norm” and of topics that are taboo/stigma?
I wonder when people will open their eyes completely to “see” than to just “look”.
@Scorpria,
Ooops, I’m really late replying your comment! Yes, I do read Tbg’s blogs. 🙂 You are spot on about when people will ‘see’ rather than look!
hey shail…you should read a book called bitter chocolate…it was such an eye opener and a must read for anybody with kids. Will go check out the CSA page too.
@arch,
I will definitely read it. Have noted other references to it too 🙂