I am participating in the 30 Days Letter Challenge where you write one letter each day. The 3rd in the list is a letter to ‘Your Parents’
Dear Parents,
This is going to be a long one. So I suggest you collect your reading glasses, get yourself something warm to drink, some snacks may be and settle down in your favorite chair. Ready? So here I am, writing you a letter. Not that I haven’t done so earlier. I have, in the past, from the hostels I stayed in, from the places I lived in after my marriage, long, newsy letters about what was happening in my life. In fact I particularly remember the time once I neglected to write for a long period of time (teenagers have different priorities) and, you called me up at the college hostel.
When I came running to get the call, you asked me without any preamble, injecting your question with that right note of sarcasm you were good at, which I should have been used to by then, but unfortunately I never was,
“So, are stamps and envelopes not being sold in the post office there?”
My face fell. But how would you know? You were on the other side of the phone. Probably patting yourself on the back for what you considered a witty question. You know what strikes while I write about it after all these years? I myself am a parent now. If I don’t hear from my own children, it is worry that fills my heart. The first question I ask is, ‘How are you? Is everything okay?’ But then, I am not you. I took great care not to ever be.
You as parents, gave me life, food, shelter and home, an education, and also married me off at the ‘right’ age as society demanded. But is that all? I understand that there is another ingredient essential to a growing child. It is called ‘love’. I don’t remember ever knowing what that was. I know the arguments people put forward, that the food, shelter and all the rest are all about love. Really? I mean like r.e.a.l.l.y? So then the children in orphanages would lack nothing if provided food, shelter and clothing?
You know, you are my teachers, but not in the way you think. I picked up each and every point of what NOT to do when I grew up and had a family of my own, from you. You compared me unfavorably to my siblings, not once, not twice, every single time till I started believing that I was indeed a dunce compared to them. I could never do anything right in your eyes. You went out of your way to tell me I was not good looking enough. At 12 I hid my report card, too scared to show it to you because my ranking had dropped to a two figure number for the first time ever. You blamed ME for the loafers who roamed the area to gawk at the young girl living in the neighborhood. You came down on me heavily when I stood in front of the mirror and innocently remarked how I was going to plait my newly cut shorter hair when I would be joining the new school. Small things, eh? I cannot bring myself to talk of the bigger ones. I am not yet ready you see. I don’t think I will be, even on my deathbed.
I don’t know if you have heard of the movie The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. He was born looking like an old man and then aged backwards. That’s my life, except that it is not in looks that I felt old. It was the way I was treated, like someone your age, who should have come with all the knowledge pre-loaded. I was never allowed to be a child of my years. I felt weary and much older than my age. It is only when I had my own children that I realised with a shock that I never had a childhood so to speak of. But somewhere along the way, I learnt to snatch happiness from wherever I could. And also to smile.
I firmly believe that there are some things that if we take up, we are obliged to do justice to it, parenthood being one such. So I went out of my way to live my life as an example. Of course, I did make mistakes in spite of the care I took because I had inadvertently imbibed some wrong lessons from you. Still, I tried hard to not repeat the major ones I recognized. Mostly, I accept that I have not been a perfect parent, which is a far cry from the attitude you have. You have done everything perfectly, you never forgot to repeat at frequent intervals to me, much to my indignation and also amusement. Yes. After all I am older now and capable of amusement at yesterday’s wrongs done to me.
All my life I have blamed you as parents. But now, I have to apologize. No, it is not what you think, that having brought up children of my own I have come to understand you have always been right. That’s nothing but nonsense trotted out by fools, a foolish notion fit only to be shared on Facebook every now and then by those with herd mentality. Having a family of my own only underlined the stupidity of what you kept saying. “You will know when you have a family of your own.” How wrong you were. So what has changed now, you wonder?!
The truth I realised, is that, you have been victims of a society that thinks marriage and family are the be all and end all of life. You were forced into a life that the society thought fit for you, without ever getting a chance to think for yourself if that is the life you wanted, a life with which you went along quietly because you knew no better. You married simply because your parents said so. You had children because that was supposed to be the next logical step to marriage. No thought went into anything. It was just a matter of running with the herd, a run which you did automatically without really having any interest in it. I feel sorry for the talented people that you are, destroyed by society’s dumb rules, and how your offspring (I became your favorite punching bag. What unity you displayed in this one matter!) had to bear the burden of your subconscious frustrations. What amazes me is how you still cannot ‘see’ and how you still uphold the same life as a good example to follow. I rest my case. What else is there to say?
I will not end this letter with love and what not. Those are alien words for me. Don’t let all this bother you into thinking I will not care of you. I will. I do set store by duty.
Your daughter, who always grew up thinking she was adopted.
©Shail Mohan 2014
It brings to my mind one of our old chats about learning from our parents.. What to do and what not to do. You and I , I think have picked up more of the nots.
I don’t understand why parents are so bent into molding their children into a mini version of who they are, or even who they wanted to be.. not who the children themselves want to be.
In trying to do what they think is good, they damages to their kids
The Nots more than the Dos. I understand that so very much!
🙂
Pingback: Letter writing, anyone? | Shail's Nest
As you so rightly said, your parents (like most at that time) were victims of society – their parenting style was a learned behaviour – learnt from observing their own parents and extended family. At that time, going against the grain wasn’t an option…Having an opinion was frowned upon…
Two weeks ago on my 42nd. birthday my mother called to wish me…She said she missed the young me when I did what I was told i.e. didn’t express my opinions…Now that I have opinions galore, it’s hard for her to control me…My mother has given me tons of love and has done a lot for me and still continues to do so, but she can’t get over the fact that I have different ideas on raising my daughter – not all ideas are different just some…she still thinks she knows best…
There is much much much that resonates deep inside, Shail, though perhaps I will never have the guts to be as forthright as you are, and have always been. I do love them, but there are these things, these things that will always remain as a hard painful knot, that will never be untied, not in this lifetime 🙂
And yes, the way one is a parent – taking care not to be the way ours were. So much so that when the FB says, Careful, you sound just like Ammumma- I blink, am shocked more than I can tell you, and make amends like immediately.
Hugs, Shail. Just like that 🙂
Oh yes I have learnt how not to raise kids from mine. How not to treat kids, HW not to judge and mostly how not to force your opinions on them and how not to ostracize them :-). Life’s lessons well learnt.
{{hugs}}, Shail! It takes courage to write as forthrightly and honestly as you do and I truly appreciate that quality in you! To recognize the wrongs that your parents did and not repeat them to your boys shows your level of self-awareness, and that’s again something I love about you!
Hugs, Shail!
Shail, Just wanted to say thank you for this post.
What if I said what Ushus said? Just writing is a scary prospect . I see a middle born bro struggling not to be like dad. The gruff, super strict army dad that he was. And I see myself struggling too. (((hugs)))
Shail I love you for always being forthright with what you feel. It takes guts to write what you did. At many levels it resonates with what I feel, especially “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button”. This is exactly what I felt when I saw it. I truly believe I am aging backwards; that my story started only about a decade back; that I am growing young with each passing day, in my thoughts and in every other way.
helloooooooooo This one reminds me a lot of the good old days, actually when we were at that age we did not think that much but now that we have reached a age all old memories come running. I remember the Letter writing episode myself, i was in hostel every sunday we had to write letters and one year i found a penpal and started writing to “HER” 🙂 .. and my mum-dad came over with 100 odd those inland blue letters and said i can use those , and as you said my face-head-neck everything Fell to the floor 🙂
but those were different days i guess … I had lot of restrictions but then I got away with most as i did all my schooling and college in hostel so i was always away..
I loved this post shail mam…thats all i will say 🙂
Am amazed at the bitterness which comes through
How much of it evoked in the comments too
How sad that there are so many faults
Nothing nice in the memory vaults
“Thanks for nothing”, does that really hold true?!
Hugs shail. Though I really don’t know you much, I hope it is still okay to hug… memories like this always hurt us in places we never know even existed. I truly hope there is lots more love not only in the families of tomorrow, but also the in the ones who have already seen the worst.
{{{hugs}}}
You are the most sweetest and nicest person I met through blogs. Sending lots of love and hugs :*
So much pain here, Shail. Even though I’ve consciously tried avoiding certain hurtful words that my mother would use when she was angry, I think there are some hurts that parents end up inflicting in thinking that they know what is best for their child. I feel as if I’ve been on both sides of this battle. Big hugs
I can read through the lines the pain you have endured in not being able to tell many things on their face all these years. It is a good way to let it out. I can see myself at some places. I always tell my friends I am aging reversely.
Shail, I wish I could tell half of those things to my family. Not just parents alone. My mom did the best she could, I can say. But her sisters who are also a part of the family and who we still fear to say something in order not to hurt them; I want to say many of these things. How they think they are correct and how big of hypocrites they are in real.
This forebodes the kind of letter my kids will have for me some day. What will they have to tell me, I wonder.I have to be a more consistent parent, I feel. It is not yet too late, I hope. Appreciate your frankness.
That is intense now! In many places I can recall instances of me and Hrishikesh talking; and even some conversations between me and Shantanu (my husband). Times and generations change faster than we really think they do and change is something everyone of us is resistant to! I’ve had a beautifully cordial relationship with my folks and I am the other way round, trying to learn most of it. However, yes, despite their broad outlook and openness, that school of thought they beheld somewhere, I didn’t fit there. And that is when I realized, I would nurture my child with values and enable him/ her to think and take decisions independently, just like my parents did. But then, I will have to be open to whatever comes up out of that independence, unless it is gravely wrong. Beautiful post. Says a lot!
Wowsies, this is such a GOOD post but late again! Would love to hear your thoughts on this.
The way your parents treated you is very similar, well my dad is not so much and very easy to talk to, however I can relate with my mom. If I try to explain that things have changed and people look at things differently now, i only get “you need to change your attitude” and when something goes wrong and not entirely my fault..it’s because I never had “discipline” when younger. I asked her how to identify something and I got a ranting for not doing things at home (which is not entirely true) and that I learned nothing while living on my own (?!! BULLSHIT). I learned the basics of cooking and cleaning to survive, and I mentioned before that you’ll eventually learn more overtime, but I do is NEVER satisfying!! She has mentioned about being able to run a household, which is indeed true, but it’s evident I’m supposed to be some kind of superwoman who is the goody good DIL, with the “cultured and traditional” thinking who can be stomped by everyone and in-laws, never speak out and voice an opinion and think men are first and priority who can enslave you if they want. What’s ironic is she started mentioning my cousin (whom I love dearly) who tends to be better than me after she spent 2 years complaining about her and how she never knew a damn thing as she never cooked and clean, and now since she’s married with a kid, she’s “better” than me (eyeroll). I mentioned this to her to make her come to her senses, and funnily enough she contradicted herself saying that my cousin did do those things after spending 2 years ranting how she knows nothing. Plus my cousin is very lucky. At least her husband , even her MIL is very supportive and help her out instead of expecting her to do everything for them, but then again her hubby had lived outside India for a while and sees things differently. My maternal side is entirely insane with their backwards thinking that explains why they are so incredibly dysfunctional. You’d def be miserable in their company. My mom complains of me avoiding her and to be honest I’ll let her figure out why on her own. There are only two things I will appreciate
1)Working hard to give my brother and I an education (which will be paid back in respect)
2) Like you said, teaching me how to NOT raise my children (if I have any).
I’m so glad India is changing and the mindset is now becoming very different. Even in Kerala, the youth are so disgusted by the way the society is and are now fighting back. Thank god! Time to go back to my apartment and get away from the craziness!
So glad to see this. This happened so recently that I just had to vent it out!
God bless you Shail ! We need more people like you!