Most evenings I can hear the musical tinkling of the chilanka from the house across the lane, as the two pairs of feet of the young girls residing there, try to keep pace with the strident tones of tha-tha hai-thi-thi-thai from the dance master. At such times, I am taken back to a time, more than four decades ago in Vijayawada, when a dance master used to present himself at our house in the evenings, to teach the sis and I the intricacies of Kuchipudi.
By the time I learnt to appreciate and love classical dance, we left Vijayawada for our hometown in Kerala, and the powers-that-be (read, parents), under the critical influence of more powers-that-be (read Older-relatives-who-think-they-know-best) decreed that dance was a big no-no for girls. Why? For one, the devdasis danced. So, dance was for wanton females and not for those born in ‘good’ families. Besides, no husband is ever going to let the wife dance, so what’s the point anyway? Why let the girl pursue a hobby that the groom’s family might frown upon in the future? Though I did not know the term ‘stuff and nonsense’ those days, in the present I know that’s what I wanted to tell the powers-that-be and their influence-rs.
How odd it seems that people accepted (still do) as given that girls/daughters were born for the express purpose of being groomed (trained) for marriage. Most parents so entrusted, took their job pretty seriously. What amazes me is HOW down the centuries, parents of female children have been convincingly conned into believing that daughters are ‘property’ left in their safe-keeping temporarily, something ‘which they had to hand over to the rightful owners (read the husband’s family) when the time came. I mean, wasn’t there anyone at all with brains enough to see through this con game and protest? Apparently not. People just did what was told them (and took pride in it); generation after generation unfailingly groomed girls for their much hyped ‘destiny’ of ‘serving’ (Oh! What a noble sacrifice it is, that only a woman can do!), the socially higher-ups aka parents of boys, In the meantime they waited greedily for their quota of the goodies, that is if they had male children. Don’t be misled into thinking we are in the modern age and such things do not happen. Life for the vast majority still runs on similar lines, education and awareness notwithstanding.
Anyway, getting back to what I was talking about, as a girl child, further lessons in dance was denied me. Being too young, (I was eleven) and not really well-versed in the art of getting-my-way-at-all-costs, which incidentally is an art all by itself, a form in which I regret to say I fail dismally to this day, I had to watch helplessly as my dream slipped through my fingers. Instead, I was initiated into something ‘harmless’, more “suitable” for a girl child, namely learning the string instrument called veena.
A music teacher was promptly arranged and it was once again lessons in the evening, three times a week. Already smarting from loss of something I loved, this came as a blow. Gone would be those evenings when I was free to play with the cat, listen to music, bury my nose in books or daydream to my heart’s content.
Soon a new routine was in place. Once I was back from school, veena lessons would commence and when that was done, it would be time for evening bath and homework. On days that I did not have lessons I had to practice. The skin on my finger pads broke and hurt like hell, but I had to keep going as only then the skin would harden enough to take the pressure of running over the strings endlessly. Under duress it was, but eventually I learnt to play the veena and had my first formal recital in front of the Goddess in the nearby temple.
The day I left home for college and hostel was the day I left the veena and the lessons and the memories associated with it behind, both physically and mentally distancing myself, vowing never to connect with that part of me again. There is nothing I hate more than being forced to take up something, anything. I don’t care who is doing the forcing, I simply hate to be forced, pushed, maneuvered, manipulated….
Years later I tried helping my children choose some hobby they’d like to take up, determined to support them in their pursuit. But they did not seem to have the necessary passion to pursue the extracurricular interests they professed. I tried prodding them a few times, remembering my own lost opportunity. But one day it dawned on me, it is not necessary that we all be performers. We need an audience too, the appreciators. Besides, that had been me in the past, this is them in the present, two different entities. So I let them be.
In case you are wondering, both have their own hobbies now which I never would have dreamed of all those years back when they were kids. One treks, does rock climbing (he has Half Dome under his belt) and the other plays basketball, designs (take a look at my book cover here) and strums his guitar.


Over centuries, ‘Destiny’ has been used to con all kinds of people into accepting the status quo. Not just women/girls and their parents, the poor have always been conned into believing that they are meant to be poor, the Raja is meant to be the Raja, the ‘praja’ is meant to be the ‘praja’, etc., etc.
There were many people ‘with brains enough to see through this con game’. Many were emotionally blackmailed by their parents into refraining from protesting. Some who protested were ‘taken care of’ by the vested interests, leading all and sundry to ‘knowingly’ say, “That’s what happens if a person doesn’t know his/her limits!” Only a few succeeded in doing their own thing. The most unfortunate part is the same people behave differently in different situations. For example, there are people who suffered atrocities from their daughter’s parents-in-law, but gladly perpetrated the very same atrocities as the parents of their son.
It’s important that those of us who are ‘enlightened’ should ensure that we practise what we preach. I know from personal experience that it’s easier said than done, but we must keep trying.
That was a nice book cover!
The last part left me heartened. After an abortive push to make him learn guitar, left son to his football, realized early enough that he is my son after all – push makes me run in the opposite direction at double the speed.
As for girls being pushed to do what they are ‘supposed’ to, the bad taste is something that is so difficult erase. I still remember the person, the time and the place, an uncle said in that dismissive voice of his, ‘CA? Is that for girls?’ 🙂
My Amma did her Arengetram in Bharatnatyam at the age of 9. The only reason she was allowed to learn to dance was because she was terribly asthmatic as a child and one of the doctors suggested dance as a form of exercise for her. and funnily because her teacher (male) used to be drunk at times when she used to go to learn dancing, my paati sent my eldest mama with her in the class. And my mama dances very well too :):) by just observing!
Its sad you didnt learn to dance 😦 but you play the veena..how awesome 🙂 I loved that picture 🙂
Your sons have awesome hobbies no?
Its quite a challenge is it not?!
So many times I have to stop myself from telling my son, that he said he wants to be a cricketer and so you must learn this and hone your skills and all that… so many times I have to just tell him to play like he wants and have fun.
When my wife enrolled him for a drawing class, I was hesitant, but son was not so hesitant so I let him go. He went a few times, but since it was early in the morning on Sunday’s it eventually fell on the wayside as laziness of the kid and more so his parents ensured he stopped pursuing it!
He then came and asked to join Tae-Kwondo in school, we allowed that but in about 3 months he didn’t want to go there again. We allowed him to stop it as well.
Sometimes, no most times I am confused whether to let him just be and let him come and ask me if he wants to learn something and join some coaching or should I kind of lead him to learning something I really am unsure. At what point should I put my foot down and tell him he has to do this is beyond me. My wife, even my Mom sometimes feel I just have not being insistent enough and that I let my son have his way a little too much.
Its a fine line I guess what to allow, where to stop him and where to encourage him… I guess I will only learn once he grow’s where I erred and where I did well….
Life is not as simple is it!?
Ah Shail, that was our generation … and we were curbed and suppressed for a long time until we were forced to become rebels. I see some parents do it even now. Sadly such parents never enjoy their kids, or know them at all
Shail, I think you can start it all over again now.. I started learning veena and vocal singing just 4 months back. I am happy that I have started it again.. So, you want to dance again, Do it now.. I am sure you will inspire many Women to pursue their interest . :).
Shail, every word you have written are echoes from my heart. There are so many similarities we share.
I too wanted to learn dance when I was in school. My friends learnt Kathak from a lady who came to school on alternate days. But I was not granted permission for the same reason. It was not a respectable hobby. I was too docile to protest. I carried on with my life and did many things out of social pressure. But I had one dream…that if I had a daughter, I would definitely introduce dance to her.
My second born was a daughter, Priya. When she was an infant she used to sway to any tune she heard. Later she started doing difficult moves. Soon I realised she had a passion for dance. When she was three I tried putting her in a nearby dance class. The teachers refused because according to them 7 is the right age to start dance. My little daughter tried convincing the teacher that she was 7. Anyway she started classes at the age of 7. Not one day she missed a class. Then the teacher started coming home to teach her. She attended classes till std 10 but had to stop due to board exams of 10th and 12th. But was always on stage at school, at college.
She completed her engineering from an NIT and joined a tech company. 8 months later I get a call from her saying “Mummy, I’m quitting my job and making a change in my career” “What career?”. Her answer “Dance”. I was okay with her decision. Her dad tried to convince her to join his company but she had made up her mind. She started her own dance company called “Piah Dance Studio” and is doing great. It’s three years now. I’ve just returned from a show with tickets all selling out. Btw, she is married and has a very supportive husband and in laws. In fact her husband had a big role to play in this production right from the beginning to the end. He and all her friends are a great support system to her and each other. She and her team are always happy, creative and excited.
If interested you can visit her at “Piah Dance Studio” on facebook and see her work.
Thanks Shail you have reminded me of my journey and my daughter’s.
I am still dreaming to fulfill my dreams some day.. I have time now but not the circumstances..
Wishing you that all your dreams come true! 🙂
You know, Shail, no matter what activity you take up, be it something of your interest or otherwise..when you’re pushed or forced into it, you lose interest in it, the whole charm gets lost, in my opinion. I grew up with music all around me, and I loved it. I loved singing( still do) , performing, etc. But I never used to look forward to my classic music lessons, probably because I used to feel forced to follow a very strict regimen by my grand parents.
I’m glad you eventually distanced yourself from that unpleasant phase and moved on to doing things that interested you more 🙂
Just a thought, why dont you take up dance again, Shail? Maybe start learning again? It’s never too late you know 🙂
I agree, go for it, Shail
Recently I met a family where both the children sing. The girl has to be pushed a little, but has the desire to sing. So that is okay. As for the younger son, he forced his parents and the teacher (who thought he was too young), to let him attend music class. Now he is 7 or 8 and is a good singer.
Now I have other dreams, Deeps. I will settle for them, like may be photographing a rare bird 😉 😛
Some dreams fructify some don’t. (Corny) I am sure your latest dream is on it’s way to getting realized.
I think you have got it wrong 😉
Nice, simple writing.
Thank you and welcome to Shail’s Nest 🙂
I know what you mean! I got my way by making it (being allowed to attend dance school) a condition if my mom wanted me to continue my singing lessons. They made all kinds of excuses about how it would affect my singing voice but I held firm! I greatly enjoyed the dance school and did several group dances on stage!
You are/were a strong girl it appears 🙂 Good for you that you could do both.
Same story here, ” what !!! girls from good families dont dance” what’s good families ? i dont know .
Anyway I started to learn after i started work, living alone, it was a nice hobby , kept m ein shape and continued after marriage, after 15 yrs i stopped, i still dance ( when my old bones permit and when i feel I’m unnecessarily gaining wt)
it’s the best form of exercise, keeps one supple and moving and fun, melodious and IMO non-boring. i cant run or exercise mindlessly on a machine, some dance + walking outside i hope is enough to keep me without illness. we’ll see.
That’s wonderful that you could, Radha. I am so happy for you 🙂
Sigh. The notions dinned in, the dreams crushed, the story of many a young girl, till she can make her choices, at some point. I do know. But then there is another dream to chase and yet another, and that is the best part of life. How it never stops or lets you 🙂
All those dreams of travelling. Sigh 🙂
I find that interesting that girls who don’t dance/sing..etc are ‘good girls’ and who are being prepped for marriage. I always saw the opposite, at least in the West where some girls were forced to sing/dance and have no choice..etc as having that will make them more suitable for the marriage market (or perhaps show ego/status from the family). I don’t sing/dance so maybe I’m not a proper malayalee (well I considered 50% mallu and 50% american) and an outcast in Kerala lol, but I do have interests that considered not the norm. I love to make a difference in people’s lives, do charity work to help people who are in need, I love animals and learning about them..especially dogs, and lately I developed a interest in doing outdoor sports like hiking, kayak..etc.. And I really do like to cook and explore new dishes, except when I’m at home with my parents, since they put so much burden on that it rubs you the wrong way.