Tags
All of us look at the Taj Mahal and marvel at its ethereal beauty. But very few of us stop to ponder about the hard work that went to erecting this marvellously beautiful monument. The sweat, blood and tears that were shed, the limbs and lives lost. Who thinks of all that? Maybe a handful. The same happens when people look at a smiling face and a happy family. They think the smiling face was born that way and never had to face any adversities in life. They assume the ‘happiness’ was gifted to the family on a platter, with watercress around it. They forget that behind every smiling face and the cheerful family whose happiness is envied are stories just like anyone else’s, different only in the finer details.
I marvel when I see people go all misty-eyed remembering their lost childhood, wanting to make a return trip to those unforgettable times. Yes, I do admit we all have memories, good and bad. But if you ask me, I personally don’t own a single happy memory of my childhood, not a measly one which I can revisit and say, “Oh how wonderful it was then. I wish I could relive it all over again!” In spite, I did something else which others seemed to have missed doing in their carefree childhood: I observed what happened around me. I analysed what I so observed, I thought hard about what the solutions could be to problems, I came to my own conclusions (or admitted to myself that I did not have an answer, but vowed to go on searching for it) and made mental notes on what I was going to do (and of course what I was not going to let happen too) when I had a family of my own.
That is when were sown the seeds on how I was going to raise my own children. I picked up more inputs on the way through life, from some more of observing as also a lot more of reading and introspecting. But I certainly had no idea what I was letting myself in for, for having such clear cut ideas and opinions on child rearing.
In our society marriages and children happen as a matter of course. There is no planning beforehand. It is worse in the case of arranged marriages. Even before the man and woman get to know each other, they find themselves parents of children. You will find that new parents have hardly given any thought on how exactly they want to bring up their children. Interestingly, they would not even have deemed such thoughts necessary. And horror of horrors, they are actually inordinately proud of this stupid attitude of theirs. “That’s how we have been living for centuries” say some smugly. “We grew up this way and look at how we have turned out. What’s wrong with us?” ask others in earnest. All I can say is: just look around you my dears and see for yourself what centuries of living without any responsibility has done to us. But of course, isn’t it much easier to blame the Big Bad West and its influence, and be done with it? Besides which, why are these so-happy-with-everything-as-it-has-been people so busy running after latest gadgets, styles and what not? Why are they not travelling in a bullock cart or better still, living on trees?
Anyways, these questions of what’s wrong with old ways were asked in my home too when I tried to initiate discussions on how we as parents were going to rear the child yet to be born to us. I am far thinking that way. I was only a few months preggers at the time. What were the things we were agreed upon and where lay the differences, if any? Was it possible to iron them out and reach a consensus? It is always better as parents to have such a general idea instead of waiting for differences to crop up later and then go at it hammer and tongs in the heat of the moment. That was/is my reasoning. Incredulous looks and amused laughter was what I got in return. This chit of a girl thinks she knows more (and better) than what’s been followed for centuries? What, if anything new, is SHE going to do? Hyuk hyuk hyuk. She who should be asking her revered elders for tips and follow them to the letter is trying to steer her own course?! Of course I turned red in mortification and annoyance, but I had no intention of letting things be.
When it was realised I was serious, I faced stiff opposition all the way. I had to fight furiously and sometimes secretly (I don’t approve of parents who discuss and argue about kids in front of them) to get my way. You might ask, why MY way? Did I think mine was the ONLY way that would work? Not at all. I am always open for conversations. But if no one had anything better to suggest other than a bland, ‘What’s to decide on child rearing?’, then I find no reason why I should not insist that MY way be enforced. At least it is a ‘way’ not a ‘whatever’ sort of outlook.
It wasn’t easy. There were times I wanted to give up the fight. Giving up half way is so easy you know. You always have the comfort of convincing yourself you tried and lost. You see, I am not a born fighter, I am a persistent giver-up, and someone totally devoid of any ambition, hence have not only given up things half-way through many times, but never even attempted those things which I could probably crack. But these here were my children. I wanted the best for them. If I did not fight for getting them what I considered the best upbringing, then who would? So I had to take up cudgels on their behalf. This earned me enmity from those around, and undeserving names such as arrogant, snooty, stand-offish, thinks no end of herself, think she is too good for the likes of us yada yada. Yes, in India, if you are a woman (and a ‘mere’ homemaker at that), have convictions, express an opinion in confident tones and dare to follow it up, you are branded as all of the above.
Yet, I stood up, became a tigress, for my children’s sake, fighting off anyone who wanted to see them just one more in a herd of sheep. Starting with me insisting on breastfeeding my first born with opposition from all sides, it was a fight all the way. A colicky baby in your hand makes experts of everyone with even a single goddamn grey hair on the head. I was forced to take a stand with such ‘wise’ ones, that my baby was not a guinea pig for them to experiment their various cures. I insisted to those around me that my authority not be belittled in front of my children. I refused to meekly accept the actions of those who tried to pamper the children or support their tantrums in a bid to undermine my authority and get into the children’s good books which I feel is the cheapest trick in the book. I refused to join the ‘grades are everything’ platoon and in this matter I had to take on teachers as well. I encouraged the children to have minds of their own, do things differently. I refused to treat them as serfs, which was more common way of treating children in the past. Parents are NOT Gods. I defy the ‘matru pitr devo bhava’ that everyone quotes. Parents or for that matter teachers, are just guides and mentors to children. Our duty is only to prepare them for life, not make children into obedient (and in the process spineless) and subserviant little pet robots. Unfortunately that’s what most parents aim for, some unknowingly.
Years later I reaped the fruit of my hard labor, the battle I waged almost single-handedly. No, not just in the form of children who respect and love their Mom. The parents, in-laws, other relatives, friends, and of course the children’s Dad all admitted (some directly some others only indirectly and very, very grudgingly) that I had been right and had done a good job. But do remember the story of the beautiful Taj Mahal, and the sweat and blood that lies behind it. I was not always right. Sometimes I failed, especially the times I lost my cool and instead of the firm reasonable approach screamed my lungs out at them. That’s my only regret and something I would go back to if I could and change.
This post is about standing up for my boys. That is actually a lot easier in our society. People are a bit lenient when it comes to male children. After sometime they leave you alone. You know what folks, what I would have loved would have been to stand up for a couple of girls. Now that would have been really something. I know on reading this, my sons may end up accusing me (*sob sob*) that I prefer daughters to sons. But really speaking, just think of the amount of standing up I would have had to do for daughters?! I could have actually had double the fun roaring and mauling the eyes off those who dared clip their wings.
Written for the Women’s Web ‘I stood up’ Blogathon

“arrogant, snooty, stand-offish, thinks no end of herself, think she is too good for the likes of us” I have been called all those and now I revel in those adjectives. At least it means that I’m not a hare-brained twit!! 😀
I applaud you for fighting and helping your boys to become independent, responsible adults. Yes, I’m sure you would have done a fantastic job bringing up girls…I regret that there are not too many moms like you who will willingly let their daughters fly!
Hope you get better very soon!
Thank you Aa’s Mom 🙂
I so agree with what you have written. You sound so much like me what I’m today. Since I’m working and need in-laws support for child rearing it makes it even more difficult. If I convey how a certain thing is to be done with the child, I’m implicitly told that we are not your servants to obey what you want. 😦 They feel its their right to do what they want because they are rearing the child.
There are times when I give up and there are times when I stand up. Earlier it would affect me a lot facing these tussles. But now that I’m not in the good books, it doesn’t matter. I say what I want to.
I can so relate to what you are saying. 🙂
BTW, welcome to Shail’s Nest 🙂
I enjoyed reading your post, Shail! Yes, I also like to do things in a planned way and luckily for me, I had the support of my mil and my husband in my ideas about bringing up my sons. My husband and I try to thrash out any differences of opinion that we might have privately about specific decisions. I also agree that though we teach our children to respect elders, it is not a blanket statement. That respect must always be reinforced by actions on the part of elders. And, discussion is always promoted in my family just like my own father did when we were going up! I would have loved to have a girl too. It is a well-known fact in my family that I prayed that I be blessed with a girl :). Glad to know your experiences.
Welcome to Shail’s Nest Rachna. Its good to read about the support you had. 🙂
*Stands up and applaudes*
You are a total inspiration honestly!! big big hugs
*Takes a bow* Hugs back at ya 🙂
you are so true shail.. we need to become tigress to protect our kids and fight with the world.. all the best for the contest..
Thanks 🙂
A beautifully written post Shail. Loved it.
Thank you Amit 🙂
Loved reading this. My mother went through something similar and I love her for how I’ve turned out today 🙂
Welcome to Shail’s Nest 🙂 and thank you.
Absolutely loved your post! You have said it all!!
Even now, I see parents with 2 kids and they are so freaking lazy and irresponsible it gets my goat!
and they have the audaucity and arrogance to question our decision to wait before having children so that we are mentally and emotionally ready to have and raise them!
My advice to whoever wants it always has been::
(1) Marry only if/when you want to.
(2) Have children only if/when you want to.
Glad you liked the post 🙂
Such a long winded article. Much ado about nothing.
Thank you. That is indeed my field of expertise, writing long posts on absolutely nothing. In fact I have no intention of competing with the “interesting” TOI pages.
“I defy the ‘matru pitr devo bhava’ that everyone quotes. Parents or for that matter teachers, are just guides and mentors to children. Our duty is only to prepare them for life, not make children into obedient (and in the process spineless) and subserviant little pet robots”
Thankyou so much for saying this out loud. I was beginning to think I was the only one thinking in this manner.
Came here from Women’s Web though ofcourse I come here from IHM’s blog too. Hopefully when we have children I hope I will be able to stand up for them too like you have done.
Your first time here, Rahmath? If so, welcome to Shail’s Nest 🙂
Good luck for the standing-up!
Respect.
Having two of my own, and being part of a set up that is lenient to the boy, rather than the girl, and yes, still having to standup for them…. yes, I do know that.
Kudos! You are an inspiration!
Thank you Usha. I met a friend of my son’s recently and was listening to his woes, of parents being cowed down by relatives and in turn trying to make him bow to their wishes. It is really sad that they as parents did not feel they should instead stand up for the son and his wishes. 😦
Beautifully written Shail 🙂
You have all my respect!
Welcome to Shail’s Nest and thank you 🙂
You know what Aunty, i read some of your blogs yesterday and I have always known about you, and with the current state of affairs at my home (the thing about would-be daughter-in-law not being treated properly), this is the thought that crossed my mind, why wouldn’t people like you have daughters and people (who think that daughters-in-law can be treated like dolls) whom i have no respect for (for this reason) have daughters. Today, i’m reading these blogs to find solace!
Also, for a few reasons, I’m not very keen on becoming a mother anymore. But i remember my school days when i used to tell my friends that there are a lot of things I would do differently (from what my folks did or i generally noticed with young parents) while bringing up my kids.
Well Anu, after a while I felt that it would be even better to have two DILs and let them lead their own lives 🙂 I too had similar thoughts, that I would do things differently. And though I don’t have daughters, I did bring up my sons differently (they will be the first to admit that). 🙂 But it is a lot difficult when your aims are different form those around you. You need a lot of strength and the will to fight and stand your ground.
And you know what, DON’T be a mother till YOU want to be one. That is important.