Perish the thought. Yes, the one that has sprung unbidden into your mind on reading the title of this post. Nope. I am NOT giving out tips on either blogging or commenting. There are enough of them around, too many if you ask me. I have a single grouse against them all. Without exception, they assume bloggers to be carbon copies of one another. Period.
A couple of years back (it could be more) I saw one such post written by someone who seemed to be well respected by the blogging community. I had opened the page with skepticism, having got the link from Twitter. What the hell was he going to tell me on how to blog? I had already decided in my mind that whatever it was, it certainly was not something I was going to agree with. You may well ask, ‘why’? I strongly believe blogging does not come with rules other than the rules of the language you write in. You are here to write what you want to, from your heart, the way you want to. I have always set great store on ‘being yourself’ as THE rule to follow. There is room for all types of us here. So why this keen interest to turn yourself into an assembly line product?
Strike me pink if the first sentence that the man wrote hadn’t charmed my pretty little pink socks off my feet. Let me clarify at the outset that this post, he wrote, of tips on blogging, is NOT for those who write for the sheer pleasure of writing or those who write for themselves.
Yes!
That is exactly what I have been trying to tell these people who were throwing rules of blogging in my face. Such as us exist who are not bothered about ‘keywords’ and ‘driving traffic’ or ‘optimum words’ (not that it is a crime if indeed you are), for we write for different reasons. For example, ‘traffic’ on our blog does make us jubilant, but that traffic is NOT the reason we write. Every other article on blogging tips suggests how 700-800 is the ideal number of words to keep your blog-readers hooked. That has never stopped me from writing posts that average at least 1500 words. You get what I mean? We’d rather write what we want and not have traffic than have traffic by writing for traffic’s sake. Unlike that fine gentleman, they of the world-is-filled-with-carbon-copies-of-me syndrome refuse to even acknowledge that people like us exist.
Next comes the comment policies. As I see it, other than expecting that the commentator should be polite and not be selling viagra or breast enhancement products, are not dropping links worse than pigeons crap on the statue in the square, I see no need to educate them. But you get to read some really balderdash-y stuff about how and what we should and should not write as comments. Like, r.e.a.l.l.y?
One of the rules, oft repeated in all seriousness admonishes about leaving generic comments like, ’Nice!’ ‘Good one’ etc. But tell me, WHAT IF that is what I feel? That its nice, a good one? Why should I be asked to make up stories instead of writing down just what came to mind? I certainly don’t agree with the blogger dictating to me, the reader, HOW I should be appreciating their writing. Isn’t it upto the commentators to add to the conversation if/when they have something to say?
Some guests may come to your house with costly gifts, some with utilitarian items, others with flowers, some may walk in empty handed with a smile on their face, for a cosy chat or to enjoy the silence with you. But as a host if you start printing pamphlets giving details of what gifts are acceptable when they visit you, to me at least, it sounds extremely rude and weird a way.
Live and let blog. Don’t force comments, let them happen. My blogging mantra. What is yours?
ShethP said:
I was thinking on similar lines just today :)… that don’t like and comment as if you’re returning a favor; be genuine.
shail said:
Genuineness wins hands down any day 🙂 Welcome to Shail’s Nest and thank you.
Mysoul said:
I want to say “I wuv you” (I know that’s a tad childish so please indulge me) for writing what was on my mind. I get advice too from time to time, and I had no way to say no to it other than my standard “Loser, Lacking in Ambition Like” statement – I am not looking for traffic, comments or money, but be able to express what I think but never speak about to the ones in my life. So Thank you for saying this. 🙂
shail said:
Lol. at the wuv. But yeah, I perfectly understand your sentiments in the matter 🙂
The Vanilla Housewife said:
Amen! Totally agree especially on the commenting part!
shail said:
🙂
Amit said:
Zero comments on a post will certainly disturb me after a few years in blogging. I think it changes with time. You start having expectations. And there is another angle to the story nowadays. We all are Facebook friends too. 🙂
But yes, if you keep all this aside, it should only be about the pleasure if writing. No complications attached.
shail said:
The point is each of us have different expectations. What might seem disturbing to you might not be for someone else. 🙂 I do share links on different platforms as a matter of course and also enjoy comments. What I am against is people imposing their likes and dislikes on others as if we are all clones of each other. 🙂
Jay said:
I feel the same about those who read but dont leave a comment. I mean, ppl like me read blogs and sometimes leave the space with a smile, a frown or simply nod in agreement. The posts could resonate with my thoughts and there are simply nothing else I could add on too. That does not mean I am rude or deserve to be called a ‘lurker’. It’s nice to have readers to say hi, but resorting to name calling when they dont…hmmm, maybe its just me.
shail said:
I hear you. Sometimes there is nothing much to add to what’s been said. In that matter I like the ‘like’ option on WordPress. You can let the blogger know you have read and appreciate what’s been written. 🙂
Jay said:
‘its’ should be read as ‘it is’.
wanderlustathome said:
“Such as us exist who are not bothered about ‘keywords’ and ‘driving traffic’ or ‘optimum words’ (not that it is a crime if indeed you are), for we write for different reasons.”
Doing a ‘yippeee yippee yay yay’ dance. I could never understand all these rules. That reminds and prods me to write about ‘the best seller’ discussion at the Lit Fest in Bangalore. It was more or less on these lines 🙂
We write and comment if, when and what we feel like. Long live us!
shail said:
Yeah, long live us! 🙂 Oh do write about the best seller discussion. I hate how people put forward formulas for successful this, best selling that and so on and so forth.
sridevidatta said:
Blog and let blog is my mantra . had never been good with verbosity .Sometimes I just “Like” the post and move on . Don’t see why that would be deemed as an insult 😀
shail said:
Tell me about it, Sridevi! Some people even criticize that we have not replied to their comments, not knowing anything about our life or its schedules. That reminds me I left out an important point I wanted to say. May be another time.
Govind said:
Nice 🙂
shail said:
Thank you.
R's Mom said:
Ah! thats a wonderful post..I do leave comments like nice and LOL, and I also blog for MYSELF..keeping this as a dairy when I retire and have little to do in life and then look back and thing ‘Gee RM, you were crazy’ I do love getting comments, but honestly, I am too lazy to even categorize my posts..so not tags and stuff..you can well imagine why I blog 🙂
shail said:
See, there are many different types of us out here. Exactly my point. I hear ya! 😀
ashreyamom said:
Shail this reminds me of two post what i had written long long back.
1. http://ashreyamom.wordpress.com/2011/09/01/what-blogging-means-to-me/
2.http://ashreyamom.wordpress.com/2011/08/29/how-to-get-more-readers-to-ur-blog/
second post was my come back after long time. the time when i was desperate to get readers. certainly my idea has changed with time, but to be honest, i have tried those things written on the post to get more comments and more traffic.. i
shail said:
It is not at all wrong to use any method to get traffic, Ashreyamom. My point is just that it should be accepted that there are all sorts of people in the world 🙂
Let me check your posts 🙂
Bindu said:
Your words are soothing. Wish there will be more out there who would be ready to accept the bloggers and blogs as they are.
Have to digress a bit.
At school we have to teach how to write articles, speeches, and even stories and posters. Can someone teach imagination and creativity? I never set any limits. Why kill their creativity? Many of the students are much better and smarter than the teachers themselves. Instead of teaching we only need to inspire and later appreciate their creations with suggestions (not corrections) for improvement. These exams take away all the fun – they read and write not for the sheer pleasure of doing them but with the aim of scoring better grades. How sad!
shail said:
I agree 100% with you. Similarly, when people say blogs should be written thus and comments should follow this format, they are taking away from the whole experience.
I am sure you are a wonderful teacher from the example! 🙂
introspectingnomad said:
Nice, Good one!!
shail said:
Thanks
afshan18 said:
Live and let comments happen is true but U know some times expectations do arise 🙂 but still in blogging a saturation level comes when U don’t bother much about anything and just blog on and rock on.
I am feeling that I am nearing that stage !
Good one Shail.. Loved it
shail said:
Expectations are not bad or wrong, Afshan. But when someone says they don’t have expectations, you gotta believe them too. Both extremes exist with most concentrated in the area between the two, at various points. 🙂
manju joglekar said:
Well said, Shail! I so agree with you. There really shouldn’t be a lot of ‘rules’ about blogging and commenting.
For my part, I try to leave a ‘meaningful’ comment after I have read a blogpost. But if I have liked a post, but haven’t anything specific to say, I may write “nice!” or maybe “great post!”
As for readers commenting on my blog, I love it if they comment, but really don’t mind if they don’t. 🙂
shail said:
You echo my thoughts, Manju! 🙂 Well said.
Deboshree said:
I totally agree! Blogging is supposed to liberate. That is what it should do – in all aspects. 😀
shail said:
Bingo! I like that word, ‘liberate’ 🙂
vishalbheeroo said:
Rules are so fucked up and if there were rules for writing a novel, we would not have so many authors of rom com..I believe in writing from the heart and why shd anyone dictate to me..it’s my space.
shail said:
Creativity should not be curtailed by too many rules or we will be reading the same boring stuff again and again.
Nidaa said:
Erm… you may think has she been living under a rock? But I wasn’t aware of any such blogging/commenting rules unless you count being polite.
shail said:
How come you have missed such posts? 😛
dreamzandclouds said:
My blog is my space… I will rant and ramble on every topic under the sun with as many words I like to. And a big “boo” to the rule-setters in blogging. For me likes & comments are the ways to show that you agree/appreciate/love something the writer is talking about.
Loved the post! 🙂
shail said:
And I love your comment! (y)
dreamzandclouds said:
🙂